Starring FRANCESCA ALBANESE
Photography ILYES GRIYEB
Styling JULIE RAGOLIA
Francesca Albanese says it's Time for Change
By TIARA ATAII
The human rights lawyer and UN special rapporteur Francesca Albanese has emerged as one of the defining voices on Palestine. She discusses collective responsibility, conscience, and the meaning of luxury in the face of catastrophe.
Dress LAUREN MANOOGIAN
DURING A WORLD CUP MATCH HYDRATION BREAK THIS SUMMER, my friends and I played a game where we listed all the footballers we knew by name (I got 26—everyone else got over 100). Now, try the same game with UN special rapporteurs. There are over 40, but chances are you can only name one: Francesca Albanese.
So why is Albanese the only household name? Yes, her UN Human Rights Council mandate—special rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territories occupied since 1967—concerns, as Nelson Mandela put it nearly three decades ago, the “greatest moral issue of our time”. It sits at the nexus of extreme violations of human rights in Palestine, the complicity of western states, and allegations of censorship and media bias in favour of Israel. But there’s also what Albanese has done with her mandate. She has lent the institutional credibility of her appointment, together with her academic standing, to give voice, in plain language, to a deep malaise. A leading refugee law scholar, when I mentioned the interview, put it simply: people find Albanese “electrifying."
When I interview Albanese, her husband is driving her and their children to the beach in Sicily, where she’s from. Her answers are interspersed with, “Max, shut the boot”, “I’m doing an interview, I’ll come soon”, and “Yes, the heat is unbearable”. She tells me this is just one of 1 500 interviews she’s done in the last three years, an average of one and a half interviews a day. I put it to her that it’s a measure of the public interest in her. “I am so loved by the people and hated by the many, many governments connected to Israel’s apartheid. But I think, numbers-wise, I’m on the safe side,” she says.
Her fame has come at personal cost. After the publication of her report Anatomy of a Genocide, the cadence of the death threats she had grown used to intensified. An anonymous caller told Albanese that her daughter would be raped, and identified the school she attends. “My life has become scary at times, incredibly painful,” she tells me. “Now, for me, when you say luxury, I think of health, and I think of time with my family and friends. This is luxury for me, and it’s not rhetorical.”
All clothing PRADA
It’s a tough gig. One of Albanese’s predecessors, Richard Falk, was detained by Israeli authorities and subjected to an “extensive body search” while attempting to enter Palestine in 2008. No special rapporteur has had access to Palestine since, including Albanese, prompting one of her predecessors, Makarim Wibisono, to resign just two years into his mandate. Albanese is the first woman to serve in her role. “I’ve been waiting to write my memoir about what I experienced as special rapporteur,” she says. “I don’t think it’s been the same for my male predecessors."
A particular gripe is the double bind of media attention on her appearance. She’s either too fashion-forward and therefore, presumably, self-interested (“the look of someone who’s just stepped off a stage, more protagonist than observer”) or a try-hard hippy (“radical-chic look, radical-chic sneer, and radical-chic arrogance”). “It’s clear that I have my own style, I take care of myself, I always have a curated appearance,” she says. “People say, ‘She pretends to work for Palestine, but look at how much time she spends on her hair or her glasses.’ But why don’t they ever engage with the findings of my work?"
Given the unwanted media attention, ramifications on her security, and the impact on her personal life, does she ever think about stopping? Albanese tells me that when working at the local lido this summer on her annual report to the UN General Assembly, a client picked a fight with the manager for serving her. Though the manager sided with Albanese, it was little comfort as she sat behind her laptop while her children played on the beach. “I remember when I was in the US and I was part of the yoga community,” she says. “And I remember going around with my daughter’s stroller and I would see people sleeping in the street. And then you see people with their yoga mats talking about ahimsa—nonviolence—and just crossing over someone sleeping in front of their yoga studio. I’ve never got used to this. For people like me, this world is not an easy place. Once you know, you cannot unknow. Once you see, you cannot unsee."
"When you say luxury, I think of health, and I think of time with my family and friends. This is luxury for me."
Personal responsibility is a recurring theme in Albanese’s work. “I have understanding and empathy for people who do not know,” she says. “But once you know, you cannot pretend not to know or not to be concerned.” Albanese’s reports are addressed to the UN General Assembly, but she’s also calling upon us, the public, to take action. A frequent refrain of hers is that Gaza is a “crime scene” with “all of our fingerprints on it”, from “what we buy, where we put our savings, where our pensions come from, and the technology we use”.
“Through reading the BDS [Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions movement] guidelines, I got to know how interconnected we are in this production, consumption, destruction, non-reproduction environment,” she says, “which is what gave me the idea, together with Palestinian scholarship, to investigate the economy of occupation. I’ve stopped using Airbnb, Booking.com, Amazon, and Spotify because I try to be a conscientious consumer.”
The unprecedented scale of globalisation is overwhelming, I put it to her, and may make being a truly conscientious consumer impossible. So where does she draw the line on individual responsibility? “I don’t think that the system or globalisation is unprecedented,” she argues. “We got here, not via a series of shocks, not through a revolution, but through an evolutionary path that, from colonialism and the birth of capitalism onward, has evolved in this way. Now, what is unprecedented is the possibility for ordinary citizens to understand the system. Palestine has given us the opportunity to do our homework and realise how we are connected. I don’t think there is one day where I don’t quote at least once this groundbreaking study that was recently published by the World Inequality Lab, which says that the richest 0.001%—56,000 multimillionaires—own three times more wealth than the poorest half of humanity combined. And this also means that the decision-making power is ultimately not with states as representatives of their citizens, but with states responding to the influence of these big interests. In dictatorships, it’s more obvious. In democracies, it’s less obvious."
So is it worth trying at all? “There are people in decision-making positions at the state level that are responsible. And this is where we still have an effect. For example, Norway says they are friends of Palestine. And still, 6.9% of their sovereign wealth has been invested in businesses connected to the Israeli occupation. Then, when my report came out and the Norwegian government was confronted by their people, the leftist party [in power] committed to withdrawing their investments.”
Dress LAUREN MANOOGIAN
The end of the Norwegian case isn’t all that happy, however. Advocacy on Palestine is the proverbial three steps forward and two steps back. “Once they were in government again after the elections, they even scrapped the poor ethical guidelines that they wrote,” she says. Albanese is not uncritical of the conduct of individuals, either. “I’ve realised how selfish we are. The fact that Airbnb and Booking.com are still investing in Israel and even in the colonies [settlements] means that they have had no pressure whatsoever from outside. We prefer our own comfort. There are people who really think that they support Palestinians by putting a ‘like’ or a sad face on social media.”
Albanese does not deal in false hope. She does not offer facile solutions. “I can say with confidence that a lasting peace will require sacrifice from everyone,” she writes in When the World Sleeps. The genocide will end after consistent and widespread pressure from all corners of society, and we’re not there yet. “Again, we have not changed. It’s not that during the Holocaust Europeans didn’t know. There were ordinary Europeans in Poland, in Hungary, in Germany, in Italy, and in France who appropriated the property of Jewish people when their neighbours were put in ghettos or were sent to die at Auschwitz, Treblinka, or Mauthausen. And it’s not true that Europeans didn’t know that there were colonial crimes being committed, because there were zoos in Europe where people of colour were held until the 1960s. And look at the United States and how they treat their own non-white minorities, but also their white populations that are sadistically and cynically called ‘white trash’. So there are sacrificial communities everywhere, groups of people living on liminal lands.”
Speaking to Albanese is a different experience from speaking to most UN appointees, with whom conversations around the broader political and economic context usually become a tug-of-war back to the home base of international law. Most prefer to speak in legalese jargon. Albanese lets her emotions be known. “I always experience a sense of shock and delusion when I come to this room,” she said, visibly frustrated, in a 2024 address to the UN General Assembly. “Is it possible that after 42,000 people killed, you cannot empathise with the Palestinians?” So how does she stay sane when she’s made it her task to highlight, in part through modelling, this dissonance, frustration, and grief? “I don’t know. I really don’t know,” she says. “I’m not sure I’m sane, really. I’m trying my best to stay human, which is not easy, and not to become numb to other people’s suffering. I see the Palestinians, how, despite the pain and despite how unjust the world is toward them, how gentle they remain. And so I think that I have no reason to be less understanding and kind than them."
All clothing VÉRONIQUE LEROY
Trauma is both begotten by and shapes the assault on Gaza. In When the World Sleeps, Albanese writes that trauma left unchecked “sooner or later will inevitably manifest itself externally, potentially harming a person’s emotional, psychological, and relational abilities forever”. The genocide has unleashed a global epidemic of trauma. “Israel has made young people, its young citizens, into the executioners of genocide,” she says. “And this is a traumatic experience. Of course, it’s traumatic for the Palestinians who are being genocided or exposed to settler terror on an everyday basis. It’s traumatic for the Palestinian diaspora, who see that with a sense of impotence in the west, but also for those in Arab countries who are silenced. And then there are those who see all this, people like you and I."
So what’s the treatment for this condition? “Some of us, like me, have the possibility to speak out, and I think this is cathartic and healing. But then, of course, there are those who see and pretend not to see. Even this is a way of coping. Denial is one of the stages of trauma, like rage, like depression, and acceptance, and then feeling [that you need] to do something [to bring about] change. We all need to get to that stage of grief. For me, today, despite all the pressure, the death threats, the sanctions, and how nightmarish my life has become, I’m almost calmer. I have less anxiety because I think, ‘What matters the most to me as a person? My children, my husband, my friends, my family.’ We need to get to a level of self-consciousness that allows us to function together, to resist together, to get rid of these plutocracies and this necrocapitalism, and build something alternative and better.”
I notice that Albanese often speaks in the first-person plural: we—you and me—will resist together. When most UN appointees say “we”, they mean states and the institutions to which states have delegated authority. So where is the UN in her vision for peace in Palestine? Has it met the moment? “I don’t know. I really don’t know,” she says. “I think I managed to shift the debates and to pierce that veil of hypocrisy that was allowing Israel to hide itself behind the self-defence argument that is untenable. Have I met the moment? I don’t know, the genocide is still [going] on. How many lives have I saved? Honestly, I can’t tell you. I have the feeling that it’s very few. Sometimes I’ve even been scared that the more I challenge Israel and the US, the more vindictive they become.”
"For people like me, this world is not an easy place. One you know, you cannot unknow. Once you see, you cannot unsee."
So does she still have faith in international lawyering and human rights? “I do, I do, I do, I do, I do,” she insists. “Everything is to be tried. But what makes a difference are the masses. I know that it’s risky, and this is why it’s important that people with power, people with an established and protected status, not the refugees and the migrants, take to the streets and protest. And also, of course, the BDS movement, both in the west and in the rest of the world, because this is a grammar of ethical engagement, of ethical and responsible citizenship.”
So it’s everyday folk who will bring about peace in Palestine? I’m surprised that, as an international lawyer, she doesn’t give human rights institutions a larger part. “Yeah, look, when it comes to the human rights community, I think of Palestine Action,” she says. “I think of Jewish Voice for Peace. I think of the LGBTQI+ community, which has exposed Israel’s pinkwashing. You know, it’s the unity of the people, the unity of the struggle, and the interconnectedness of the struggle that makes a difference. Do I have faith in it? It depends. It depends on how strong this army of moral warriors stands together. We need to stand united. Palestine eventually has shown what the value ofsumud[steadfastness] is, which is a grammar of indigeneity. And it speaks to everything, everyone in every place, including in western societies, where so many are seeing their fundamental freedoms shrinking and shrinking because of necrocapitalism. So this is putting solidarity to the test.” ♥
Hair and makeup SACHI YAMASHITA at ASG using CARITA and PHYTO PARIS
Photography assistant DINA MEDDEB
Styling assistant SABRINA LEINA
Production IBRAHIM SHEBANI
Post-Production GAMMA IMAGING
THIS STORY IS TAKEN FROM LOVE A/W 27 ISSUE, AVAILABLE TO ORDER AT KD PRESSE.
*Following concerns raised after publication, we would like to clarify that UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese was not involved in the styling process or in the selection of the brands featured in the shoot.
As a condition for the shooting, Francesca Albanese had specifically asked that the clothing be consistent with BDS guidance, and relied on the LOVE styling team to take that into account.
BDS follows a strategic targeting approach, focusing on a limited number of companies for maximum impact, and distinguishes between consumer boycott priority targets, grassroots or “organic” boycott targets, and pressure targets.
While LVMH, Loro Piana and Celine are not among the BDS movement’s current priority boycott or pressure targets, they are listed on other boycott-monitoring platforms, including Boycat and Gaza.nu, which apply broader criteria than the BDS movement’s strategic priority framework.
This is very important, because the fact that a company does not appear among BDS priorities should not be understood as a broader ethical endorsement of that company. We are therefore sorry for our oversight.
Styling remained entirely the responsibility of LOVE, and our team understood the choices made to be consistent with the guidance Ms Albanese had communicated. Given her mandate and the attention the issue has since received, we nevertheless felt it important to clarify the circumstances transparently.